跳至主要內容
B2進階文法(B2–C1)· 第 13/37 課

情態動詞完成式(Modal Perfects):should have、must have、could have

Modal Perfects (should have, must have, could have)

1概述

情態動詞完成式(Modal Perfects)是「情態動詞 + have + 過去分詞(V3)」的組合,用來回頭談論過去。它可以表達後悔、責備、對過去事情的推測,以及「本來有可能、但並沒有發生」的事。

  • 結構:情態動詞 + have + 過去分詞 V3(should have gone、must have left)。
  • should have / shouldn't have:對過去的後悔或責備。
  • must have / can't have:對過去很有把握的推測。
  • might / may / could have:過去「有可能」如此,但你並不確定。
  • could have:本來有可能做到,但實際上沒有發生。

2結構

情態動詞本身永遠不變化,只有過去分詞(V3)會隨著動詞改變。

肯定句
S + modal + have + V3
She must have forgotten the meeting.
她一定是忘記開會的事了。
否定句
S + modal + not + have + V3
You shouldn't have spent all your savings.
你不該把所有存款都花光。
疑問句
Modal + S + have + V3?
Could they have taken the wrong road?
他們有沒有可能走錯路了?
進行式
S + modal + have been + V-ing
He might have been sleeping when you called.
你打電話的時候,他可能正在睡覺。
情態動詞完成式及其主要語意
FormMeaningExample
should have + V3It was a good idea, but it didn't happenI should have saved more money.
shouldn't have + V3It happened, but it was a bad ideaWe shouldn't have stayed up so late.
must have + V3I'm almost sure it happenedKenji must have left early.
can't / couldn't have + V3I'm almost sure it didn't happenShe can't have seen my message.
might / may have + V3Maybe it happenedThey may have missed the bus.
could have + V3Maybe it happened (possibility)The parcel could have got lost.
could have + V3It was possible, but it didn't happenYou could have asked me for help.
  • 口語中 have 常被縮寫成 should've、must've、could've、might've;但絕對不能寫成 should of。
  • 否定縮寫:shouldn't have、couldn't have、can't have,以及 mightn't have(少見,主要用於英式英語)。
  • have 後面要用過去分詞(V3),不是過去式:must have gone,不是 must have went。

3用法

1後悔與責備:should have / shouldn't have

用 should have + V3 表示「本來應該做、卻沒做」的好事;用 shouldn't have + V3 表示「不該做、卻做了」的壞事。對自己通常帶有後悔的語氣,對別人則帶有責備的語氣。

I should have checked the weather before we left.
出發前我早該查一下天氣的。
Amara shouldn't have sent that email so quickly.
Amara 不該那麼快就寄出那封電子郵件。
You should have told me you were feeling ill.
你應該要告訴我你不舒服的。

2對過去有把握的推測:must have

當有證據讓你幾乎可以確定某件事發生過時,用 must have + V3。這就是表示推測的 must 的過去形式(請參考「情態動詞的推測用法」)。

The streets are wet. It must have rained last night.
街道是濕的,昨晚一定下過雨。
Diego isn't answering. He must have gone to bed.
Diego 沒接電話,他一定已經去睡了。
You must have been waiting for ages. I'm so sorry!
你一定等了很久吧,真的很抱歉!

3過去不可能發生:can't have / couldn't have

當你幾乎可以確定某件事「沒有」發生時,用 can't have 或 couldn't have + V3。這個語意不能用 mustn't have。

Mei can't have taken your keys. She was at home all day.
Mei 不可能拿走你的鑰匙,她一整天都在家。
They couldn't have finished the project already. It's huge!
他們不可能已經做完這個專案,它那麼龐大!
He can't have heard you. He had his headphones on.
他不可能聽到你說話,他戴著耳機。

4過去的可能性:might / may / could have

當某件事「可能」發生過,但你並不知道實情時,用 might have、may have 或 could have + V3。這三者語意相近,可以互換。

I can't find my phone. I might have left it on the train.
我找不到手機,可能把它忘在火車上了。
Olga may have misunderstood the instructions.
Olga 可能誤會了那些指示。
The delivery could have gone to the wrong address.
那件包裹有可能寄到錯的地址去了。

5與事實相反的過去:could have

用 could have + V3 表示「本來有可能、卻沒有發生」的事,也可以用來表達輕微的責備或慶幸。

Why did you take a taxi? I could have driven you.
你幹嘛搭計程車?我本來可以載你的。
Be careful! You could have hurt yourself.
小心點!你差點就受傷了。
We could have won if we had trained harder.
如果我們當初更努力訓練,本來可以贏的。

4比較

學習者常把 must have + V3(推測)和 had to + V(過去的義務)搞混。

must have + V3

  • 表示推論:你認為某件事發生過。
  • 是根據證據做出的猜測。
  • 與義務無關。
Her eyes are red. She must have been crying.
她的眼睛紅紅的,她一定哭過。

had to + V

  • 表示過去的義務或必要性。
  • 你確知這件事發生了。
  • 是 must / have to 用於規定與責任時的過去式。
The office was closed, so I had to work from home.
辦公室關閉,所以我必須在家工作。

5常見錯誤

✗ 錯誤You should of called me.
✓ 正確You should have called me.

should've 聽起來很像 should of,但正確的字永遠是 have。

✗ 錯誤She must have went home.
✓ 正確She must have gone home.

have 後面要接過去分詞(V3),不能用過去式。

✗ 錯誤I must have worked late yesterday because my boss asked me.
✓ 正確I had to work late yesterday because my boss asked me.

表示過去的義務要用 had to;must have 只能用於推測。

✗ 錯誤You could came earlier.
✓ 正確You could have come earlier.

表示過去的可能性要用 could have + V3,而不是 could + 過去式。

✗ 錯誤He can have forgotten about it.
✓ 正確He may have forgotten about it.

肯定句的 can have 不能用來表示過去的可能性,要用 may / might / could have。

6小技巧

💡 記住:情態動詞 + have + V3 = 回頭看過去。情態動詞表達你的態度,have + V3 把時間拉回過去。

💡 檢查事實:should have done 代表你「沒有」做;shouldn't have done 代表你「確實」做了。

💡 確定程度量表:must have(幾乎確定有)→ might/may/could have(也許)→ can't have(幾乎確定沒有)。

7快速自我檢測

1. I'm exhausted. I   to bed earlier last night.

2. The grass is wet. It   rained during the night.

3. Leila   broken the window. She was abroad that week.

4. I'm not sure where Tom is. He   missed the train.

5. Why did you walk home in the rain? I   given you a lift.