跳至主要內容
B1進階文法(B2–C1)· 第 12/37 課

表示推測的情態助動詞 (Modals of Deduction):must、might、can't

Modals of Deduction (must, might, can't)

1概述

我們用表示推測的情態助動詞 (Modals of Deduction) 來說明自己對某件事有多確定。幾乎可以確定「是真的」時用 must;幾乎可以確定「不是真的」時用 can't;只是「有可能」時則用 might、may 或 could。

  • must = 我幾乎確定這是真的。
  • can't = 我幾乎確定這不是真的。
  • might / may / could = 有可能,但我不確定。
  • 情態助動詞後面一律接原形動詞:must be、might know、can't work。
  • 這些用法談的是「現在」。要談過去,請看情態助動詞完成式 (Modal Perfects) 那一課。

2結構

把情態助動詞放在原形動詞前面;情態助動詞本身不做任何變化。

確定:是真的
S + must + V
You must be hungry after that long walk.
走了這麼長一段路,你一定餓了。
可能:是真的
S + might / may / could + V
Aiko might know the answer.
Aiko 可能知道答案。
可能:不是真的
S + might not / may not + V
The shop may not be open on Sundays.
那家店星期天可能沒有營業。
確定:不是真的
S + can't / couldn't + V
That can't be Omar. He's on holiday.
那不可能是 Omar,他在度假。
現在正在發生
S + must / might / can't + be + V-ing
Listen! Someone must be playing the piano.
你聽!一定有人在彈鋼琴。
疑問句
Could / Can + S + V?
Could she be at the gym?
她會不會在健身房?
你有多確定?
ModalMeaningExample
mustabout 95% sure it's trueShe must be at work.
may / might / couldabout 50%: it's possibleShe might be at work.
may not / might notabout 50%: possibly not trueShe might not be at work.
can't / couldn'tabout 95% sure it's not trueShe can't be at work.
  • 情態助動詞後面不加 to:要說 must be,不能說 must to be。
  • 動詞不加 -s:She might come,不是 She might comes。
  • couldn't 並不是 could(可能)的否定。It couldn't be true 表示「不可能」。要表達「也許不是」,要用 might not 或 may not。
  • 疑問句要用 could 或 can,不用 must 或 might。

3用法

1must:幾乎確定是真的

當你有充分的證據時用 must。雖然不是百分之百確定,但這是最合邏輯的答案。

Carlos has three jobs. He must be very busy.
Carlos 身兼三份工作,他一定很忙。
The ground is wet. It must be raining.
地面是濕的,外面一定在下雨。
You must know Priya. She works on your floor.
你一定認識 Priya,她就在你那一層樓工作。

2can't:幾乎確定不是真的

當證據顯示某件事不可能時,用 can't。在這個用法裡 couldn't 的意思相同。

You can't be tired. You slept for ten hours!
你不可能會累,你睡了十個小時耶!
That can't be the right bus. It's going the wrong way.
那不可能是對的公車,它開錯方向了。
The meal couldn't cost that much. It's a small café.
這一餐不可能要那麼多錢,那只是一家小咖啡店。

3might / may / could:有可能

在你只是猜測、沒有明確證據時使用。三個字意思幾乎相同,其中 may 語氣稍微正式一點。

I can't find my keys. They might be in the car.
我找不到鑰匙,它們可能在車上。
Ask Fatima. She may have a charger.
問問 Fatima,她可能有充電器。
Who's at the door? It could be the delivery driver.
誰在門口?可能是送貨員。

4might not / may not:可能不是真的

當某件事「有可能不是真的」時,用 might not 或 may not。不要用 couldn't,因為它表示「不可能」。

Lena might not be home yet. Her train was late.
Lena 可能還沒到家,她的火車誤點了。
This answer may not be correct. Let's check.
這個答案可能不正確,我們查一下吧。

5be + -ing:推測現在正在發生的事

要推測此刻正在進行的動作,用 情態助動詞 + be + V-ing。

Jun isn't answering. He must be driving.
Jun 沒接電話,他一定在開車。
They might be having lunch.
他們可能正在吃午餐。
She can't be sleeping. Her light is on.
她不可能在睡覺,她房間的燈還亮著。

4比較

推測主要分成兩大類:確定的推測和可能的推測。證據有多強,就決定你要用哪一組。

確定:must / can't

  • 你有很強的證據。
  • must = 幾乎確定是真的。
  • can't = 幾乎確定是假的。
Her coat is here, so she must be in the building.
她的外套在這裡,所以她一定在這棟建築裡。

不確定:might / may / could

  • 你幾乎沒有證據。
  • 你只是在猜測。
  • 否定形:might not / may not。
I'm not sure where she is. She might be in a meeting.
我不確定她在哪裡,她可能在開會。

5常見錯誤

✗ 錯誤The lights are off. He mustn't be at home.
✓ 正確The lights are off. He can't be at home.

表示推測時,must 的否定是 can't。mustn't 的意思是「不准、不可以」。

✗ 錯誤She must to be tired.
✓ 正確She must be tired.

情態助動詞後面要接原形動詞,不能加 to。

✗ 錯誤It may rains later.
✓ 正確It may rain later.

情態助動詞後面的動詞永遠不加 -s。

✗ 錯誤I'm not sure, but he couldn't be at work today.
✓ 正確I'm not sure, but he might not be at work today.

couldn't 表示「不可能」。要說「也許不是」,要用 might not 或 may not。

✗ 錯誤Maybe she must be ill.
✓ 正確She must be ill. / Maybe she's ill.

maybe(不確定)和 must(很確定)不能一起用,只能選一種語氣。

6小技巧

💡 想像一條確信度的量尺:must(一定是!)→ might/may/could(也許)→ can't(絕不可能!)。

💡 記住:must ↔ can't,在推測用法中它們是一組反義詞。mustn't 講的是規定,不是推測。

💡 要談過去嗎?用 must have、might have、can't have + 過去分詞 (V3)。請見情態助動詞完成式 (Modal Perfects) 那一課。

7快速自我檢測

1. Maria has been working for twelve hours. She   be exhausted.

2. That   be Kofi's car. He doesn't have a car.

3. I don't know where Sara is. She   be in the library.

4. Don't call Ahmed now. He   be sleeping. It's 3 a.m. in his city.

5. The café   be open today. I'm not sure. Let's check online.