跳至主要內容
A2基礎文法(A1–A2)· 第 54/54 課

主詞問句與受詞問句(Subject vs Object Questions)

Subject vs Object Questions

1概述

以 who、what、which、whose、how many 開頭的問句,可以問主詞(做動作的人或事物),也可以問受詞(承受動作的人或事物)。主詞問句(Subject Question)不用 do/does/did;受詞問句(Object Question)則和一般問句一樣,要用 do/does/did。

  • 主詞問句:疑問詞本身就是主詞,不加 do/does/did:Who called you?
  • 受詞問句:要用 do/does/did + 原形動詞:Who did you call?
  • 主詞問句的語序和直述句完全一樣。
  • 主詞問句通常搭配單數動詞:Who lives here?
  • 受詞問句中,介系詞常常放在句尾:Who are you talking to?

2結構

比較這兩種問句的語序。

主詞問句(現在式)
Who/What + V(s/es) + O?
Who teaches your class?
誰教你們班?
主詞問句(過去式)
Who/What + V2 + O?
What happened at work today?
今天工作上發生了什麼事?
主詞問句(否定)
Who/What + don't/doesn't/didn't + V + O?
Who didn't finish the test?
誰沒有寫完考卷?
受詞問句(現在式)
Wh- + do/does + S + V?
Who does Priya work with?
Priya 跟誰一起工作?
受詞問句(過去式)
Wh- + did + S + V?
What did you buy yesterday?
你昨天買了什麼?
同一個句子,兩種不同的問法
StatementSubject questionObject question
Maria called Tom.Who called Tom? → MariaWho did Maria call? → Tom
Kenji teaches Ana.Who teaches Ana? → KenjiWho does Kenji teach? → Ana
The noise woke the baby.What woke the baby? → The noiseWho did the noise wake? → The baby
Lena watched a film.Who watched a film? → LenaWhat did Lena watch? → A film
Omar's car hit a tree.Whose car hit a tree? → Omar'sWhat did Omar's car hit? → A tree
Ten people came to the party.How many people came? → TenWhere did ten people come? → To the party
  • 受詞問句中 did 後面一律用原形動詞:What did she buy?(不是 bought)。
  • 主詞問句要用動詞的正常形式:現在式加 -s(Who knows?),過去式用 V2(Who knew?)。
  • 就算答案是複數,who/what 後面仍用單數動詞:Who wants tea? – We do.
  • 遇到 be 動詞、情態助動詞或其他助動詞時,兩種問句都不需要 do/does/did:Who is calling? / Who are you calling?

3用法

1詢問「誰/什麼」做了動作

當你不知道主詞是誰時,就把 who 或 what 放在主詞的位置。語序和直述句一樣,不要加 do/does/did。

Who made this cake? It's delicious!
這個蛋糕是誰做的?真好吃!
What makes you happy?
什麼讓你開心?
Who wants more coffee?
誰還要咖啡?

2詢問承受動作的人或事物

當你不知道受詞是什麼時,用 do/does/did + 主詞 + 原形動詞,也就是一般問句的語序。

Who did you meet at the conference?
你在研討會上遇到了誰?
What does Hassan want for his birthday?
Hassan 生日想要什麼?
What did they order for lunch?
他們午餐點了什麼?

3which、whose、how many + 名詞當主詞

Which、whose、how many、how much 加名詞也可以當主詞,這時同樣不用 do/does/did。

Which bus goes to the airport?
哪一班公車開往機場?
Whose phone is ringing?
誰的手機在響?
How many students passed the exam?
有多少學生通過了考試?

4介系詞放句尾的受詞問句

如果動詞需要搭配介系詞(talk to, wait for, look at),介系詞通常放在句子最後面,這在日常英語中最自然。

Who are you waiting for?
你在等誰?
What is Yuki looking at?
Yuki 在看什麼?
Who did you go to the cinema with?
你和誰去看電影?

5搭配 be 動詞、情態助動詞與其他時態的主詞問句

主詞問句適用於任何時態或情態助動詞,只要把疑問詞放在整組動詞前面就好。

Who is singing in the kitchen?
誰在廚房唱歌?
Who can help me with this box?
誰可以幫我搬這個箱子?
What will happen if we miss the train?
如果我們錯過火車,會發生什麼事?

4比較

先問自己:答案是動作的執行者(主詞),還是動作的承受者(受詞)?

主詞問句

  • 答案是主詞(動作的執行者)。
  • 不用 do/does/did。
  • 語序=直述句語序。
  • 動詞要加 -s(現在式)或用 V2(過去式)。
Who helped Carlos? – Mei helped him.
誰幫了 Carlos?——Mei 幫了他。

受詞問句

  • 答案是受詞(動作的承受者)。
  • 要用 do/does/did + 原形動詞。
  • 語序=疑問詞 + 助動詞 + 主詞 + 動詞。
  • 介系詞常常放在句尾。
Who did Carlos help? – He helped Mei.
Carlos 幫了誰?——他幫了 Mei。

5常見錯誤

✗ 錯誤Who did call you?
✓ 正確Who called you?

這裡的 who 是主詞,所以不用 did,直接用動詞的過去式。

✗ 錯誤What did happen?
✓ 正確What happened?

What 是 happen 的主詞,所以不加 did。Happen 沒有受詞,因此永遠是主詞問句。

✗ 錯誤What you bought?
✓ 正確What did you buy?

What 是受詞,所以需要 did + 主詞 + 原形動詞。

✗ 錯誤What did she bought?
✓ 正確What did she buy?

Did 後面一律用原形動詞,過去的意思已經由 did 表示了。

✗ 錯誤Who live in that house?
✓ 正確Who lives in that house?

現在式中 who 搭配單數動詞,所以要加 -s。

6小技巧

💡 先想想答案是什麼。如果答案取代的是主詞(Maria called Tom),就不用 do/does/did;如果取代的是受詞(Maria called Tom),就要用。

💡 快速判斷法:Who + 動詞? =問誰做了動作;Who + did + 人 + 動詞? =問誰承受了動作。

💡 What happened? 和 Who knows? 永遠是主詞問句,絕對不要加 did 或 does。

7快速自我檢測

1. Who   the window? – Leo did.

2. What   for lunch yesterday? – I had soup.

3. Who   next door to you?

4. Who is Amara talking  ?

5. How many people   to the meeting?