Modals of Deduction (must, might, can't)
1Overview
We use modals of deduction to say how sure we are that something is true. Use must when you are almost sure something is true. Use can't when you are almost sure it is not true. Use might, may or could when something is only possible.
- must = I'm almost sure it's true.
- can't = I'm almost sure it's not true.
- might / may / could = it's possible, but I'm not sure.
- After the modal, use the base verb: must be, might know, can't work.
- These forms talk about the present. For the past, see the lesson on Modal Perfects.
2Form & structure
Put a modal before the base form of the verb. The modal never changes.
| Modal | Meaning | Example |
|---|---|---|
| must | about 95% sure it's true | She must be at work. |
| may / might / could | about 50%: it's possible | She might be at work. |
| may not / might not | about 50%: possibly not true | She might not be at work. |
| can't / couldn't | about 95% sure it's not true | She can't be at work. |
- No to after the modal: must be, NOT must to be.
- No -s on the verb: She might come, NOT She might comes.
- couldn't is NOT the negative of could (possible). It couldn't be true = it's impossible. To say "maybe not", use might not or may not.
- In questions, use could or can, not must or might.
3How to use it
1must: you are almost sure it's true
Use must when you have good evidence. You are not 100% sure, but it's the logical answer.
2can't: you are almost sure it's not true
Use can't when the evidence tells you something is impossible. couldn't has the same meaning here.
3might / may / could: it's possible
Use these when you are guessing and have no strong evidence. They have almost the same meaning. may is a little more formal.
4might not / may not: possibly not true
Use might not or may not when something is possibly not true. Don't use couldn't for this, because it means "impossible".
5be + -ing: guessing about now
To guess about an action happening right now, use modal + be + V-ing.
4Comparison
The two main groups are sure guesses and possible guesses. Choose the group by how strong your evidence is.
Sure: must / can't
- You have strong evidence.
- must = almost sure it's true.
- can't = almost sure it's false.
Not sure: might / may / could
- You have little or no evidence.
- You are making a guess.
- Negative: might not / may not.
5Common mistakes
The negative of must (deduction) is can't. mustn't means "it's not allowed".
Modals are followed by the base verb with no to.
After a modal, the verb never takes -s.
couldn't means "impossible". For "maybe not", use might not or may not.
maybe (unsure) and must (sure) don't go together. Choose one meaning.
6Tips
💡 Think of a scale: must (yes!) → might/may/could (maybe) → can't (no way!).
💡 Remember: must ↔ can't. They are opposites in deduction. mustn't is about rules, not guesses.
💡 Talking about the past? Use must have, might have, can't have + V3. See the Modal Perfects lesson.
7Quick check
1. Maria has been working for twelve hours. She be exhausted.
2. That be Kofi's car. He doesn't have a car.
3. I don't know where Sara is. She be in the library.
4. Don't call Ahmed now. He be sleeping. It's 3 a.m. in his city.
5. The café be open today. I'm not sure. Let's check online.
