Skip to content
B1Advanced grammar (B2–C1)· Lesson 11/37

Modals of Obligation, Permission and Advice

1Overview

Modal verbs like must, have to, can, may and should show how necessary, allowed or wise an action is. Use them to talk about rules, to ask for or give permission, and to give advice. They help you sound clear and polite at work, at school and in daily life.

  • Obligation: must, have to, need to = it is necessary.
  • Prohibition: mustn't, can't = it is not allowed.
  • No obligation: don't have to, don't need to, needn't = it is not necessary.
  • Permission: can, could, may, be allowed to.
  • Advice: should, ought to, had better.

2Form & structure

Most modals are followed by the base verb with no to. Have to, need to, ought to and be allowed to are special.

Affirmative (modal)
S + modal + V
You should take a break.
Negative (modal)
S + modal + not + V
Visitors mustn't park here.
Question (modal)
Modal + S + V?
Can I use your charger?
Affirmative (have to)
S + have/has to + V
Ana has to wear a uniform at work.
Negative (have to)
S + don't/doesn't have to + V
We don't have to finish it today.
Question (have to)
Do/Does + S + have to + V?
Does he have to sign the form?
Quick guide: meaning and modal
MeaningModalExample
Strong obligationmust / have toYou must show your ID.
Necessityneed toI need to call my bank.
Prohibitionmustn't / can'tYou can't smoke in here.
No obligationdon't have to / don't need toYou don't have to pay now.
No obligation (mainly UK, formal)needn'tYou needn't bring anything.
Permission (informal)canYou can sit here.
Asking politelycouldCould I leave early today?
Permission (formal)mayMay I come in?
Rules / permissionbe allowed toWe aren't allowed to use phones.
Adviceshould / ought toYou ought to rest.
Strong advice / warninghad betterYou'd better hurry.
  • Modals never take -s: she must, not she musts.
  • Modals have no -ing or past form. For the past, use had to (obligation) and was/were allowed to or could (permission).
  • Ought to and had better are fixed: ought not to, had better not.
  • Had better is about now or the future, not the past. Short form: You'd better…

3How to use it

1Obligation and necessity

Use must, have to or need to when something is necessary. Must often shows the speaker's opinion or written rules. Have to often shows outside rules (see the lesson Must vs Have to).

I must remember to call my mum tonight.
Nurses have to work at night sometimes.
You need to update the app first.

2Advice and recommendations

Use should or ought to to say what is a good idea. Had better is stronger and suggests a problem if you don't do it.

You should try the new café near the station.
Kenji ought to see a doctor about his back.
We 'd better leave now, or we'll miss the train.

3Asking for and giving permission

Can is common and friendly. Could is more polite for asking. May is formal and polite.

Can I borrow your pen for a second?
Could we change the meeting to Friday?
May I ask a question?

4Prohibition: it is not allowed

Use mustn't or can't to say something is forbidden. Not be allowed to describes rules, often made by other people.

You mustn't touch the paintings.
Sorry, you can't eat in the library.
Students aren't allowed to use phones in exams.

5No obligation: it is not necessary

Use don't have to, don't need to or needn't when you can choose. It does NOT mean "don't do it".

You don't have to wear a tie on Fridays.
Fatima doesn't need to book; the event is free.
You needn't wait for me.

6Talking about the past

Must has no past form, so use had to. For past permission, use was/were allowed to or could.

I had to work late yesterday.
When we were kids, we weren't allowed to stay up late.
At my old job, I could work from home on Mondays.

4Comparison

Learners often mix up obligation and advice. Is it a rule, or just a good idea?

must / have to (obligation)

  • It is necessary; you have no real choice.
  • Used for rules, laws and strong personal duty.
  • Not doing it can cause a serious problem.
You have to have a visa to enter the country.

should / ought to (advice)

  • It is a good idea; you can choose.
  • Used for suggestions and opinions.
  • Softer and more polite than must.
You should learn a few local words before your trip.

5Common mistakes

✗ WrongYou must to finish the report.
✓ RightYou must finish the report.

Modals like must, can and should are followed by the base verb with no to.

✗ WrongShe cans drive.
✓ RightShe can drive.

Modals never take -s, even with he, she or it.

✗ WrongYou don't must park here.
✓ RightYou mustn't park here.

Modals make the negative with not directly: must not / mustn't. Don't use do.

✗ WrongYou had better to call him.
✓ RightYou had better call him.

Had better is followed by the base verb, without to.

✗ WrongYou mustn't come to the party if you're busy.
✓ RightYou don't have to come to the party if you're busy.

Mustn't means it is forbidden. To say it is not necessary, use don't have to.

6Tips

💡 Think of a scale: should (good idea) → had better (warning) → must / have to (necessary).

💡 Mustn't = a red light (stop!). Don't have to = a green light with a choice (it's up to you).

💡 To sound polite at work, ask with Could I…? or May I…? instead of Can I…?

7Quick check

1. It's raining heavily. You   take an umbrella.

2. Tomorrow is a holiday, so we   go to work.

3.   I open the window? It's very warm in here.

4. Passengers   smoke on the plane. It's against the law.

5. Last year, Omar   work every Saturday.