Relative Clauses (defining and non-defining)
Relative Clauses
1Overview
A relative clause gives more information about a noun. It usually starts with who, which, that, whose, where or when. A defining clause tells us which person or thing we mean. A non-defining clause adds extra information and goes between commas.
- Defining clauses identify the noun. They have no commas.
- Non-defining clauses add extra information. They need commas.
- You can use that in defining clauses, but never in non-defining clauses.
- In defining clauses, you can often leave out the pronoun when it is the object.
- Do not repeat the subject or object inside the clause (~~who he~~, ~~which it~~).
2Form & structure
Put the relative clause directly after the noun it describes.
| Pronoun | Refers to | Defining | Non-defining |
|---|---|---|---|
| who | people | ✔ | ✔ |
| which | things, animals, ideas | ✔ | ✔ |
| that | people or things | ✔ | ✘ |
| whose | possession (his/her/its/their) | ✔ | ✔ |
| where | places | ✔ | ✔ |
| when | times | ✔ | ✔ |
| (no pronoun) | object of the clause | ✔ | ✘ |
- Non-defining clauses use two commas in the middle of a sentence, or one comma before the clause at the end.
- Do not use that after a comma: ~~Lisbon, that is…~~ → Lisbon, which is…
- You can leave out the pronoun only in defining clauses, and only when it is the object.
- Whom is formal. In everyday English, who is fine for objects too.
3How to use it
1Defining: saying which one you mean
The clause is necessary. Without it, the listener doesn't know who or what you are talking about. No commas.
2Leaving out the object pronoun
If the pronoun is the object of the clause (another subject follows it), you can drop it. This is very common in speech.
3Non-defining: adding extra information
The clause is extra. The sentence is still clear without it. Use commas and who or which, never that.
4which about a whole sentence
Use , which to comment on the whole idea before it, not just one noun. This is always non-defining.
5Prepositions in relative clauses
In everyday English, the preposition usually goes at the end of the clause. In formal English, it can go before which or whom.
4Comparison
Commas can change the meaning. Compare these two types.
Defining
- Tells us which one
- Essential to the meaning
- No commas
- who / which / that or no pronoun
Non-defining
- Gives extra information
- Can be removed
- Commas needed
- Only who / which, never that
5Common mistakes
That cannot be used in a non-defining clause (after a comma).
Who is already the subject, so don't add he.
Which replaces it, so don't repeat the object.
You cannot leave out the pronoun in a non-defining clause.
Use who or that for people, not which.
6Tips
💡 Comma test: if you can put the clause in brackets and the meaning is still clear, it's non-defining and needs commas.
💡 No comma, no problem for that: that is fine without commas, but a comma means "no that".
💡 To check if you can drop the pronoun, look at the next word: if it's a subject (I, she, Priya…), you can usually drop it.
7Quick check
1. The phone I bought last week has stopped working.
2. My father, is 70, still goes running every day.
3. Which sentence is correct?
4. She helped me move house, was really kind of her.
5. In which sentence can you leave out the relative pronoun?
